Scholarship News

Student Punished for Creating Class Registration Website


August 6, 2012
by Suada Kolovic
Registering for college classes takes time, patience and, above all else, persistence. If you’re a college student, then you’re familiar with the frustrating process: It’s officially your last year and the only obstacle standing in your way from victoriously crossing that graduation stage is COM: 101 – a required course you’ve been putting off since your freshman year and as luck would have it, it’s full. Now what? An extra semester? Shouldn’t schools be obligated to offer an easier, better way to register for classes? Well, a student at the University of Central Florida came up with a solution...and now he’s on academic probation.

Registering for college classes takes time, patience and, above all else, persistence. If you’re a college student, then you’re familiar with the frustrating process: It’s officially your last year and the only obstacle standing in your way from victoriously crossing that graduation stage is COM: 101 – a required course you’ve been putting off since your freshman year and as luck would have it, it’s full. Now what? An extra semester? Shouldn’t schools be obligated to offer an easier, better way to register for classes? Well, a student at the University of Central Florida came up with a solution...and now he’s on academic probation.

ADVERTISEMENT

Tim Arnold, a senior at UCF, created U Could Finish, a website that notified students when a seat was available in a given class. While the site was helpful, officials argue that it violated portions of the tech policy that prohibited students from using university tools to make money (Arnold had been charging for use of his site, taking in a total of just $7.78, he revealed) and disrupted normal technology use. Arnold plans to appeal his sanctions, which also require him to write two papers and prevent him from holding student office. “I just feel that the actions they did were very extreme, considering my intent was to help students and not to intentionally subvert the rules,” he said.

What do you think of UCF’s handling of the situation? Was it fair to put a proactive student on academic probation for trying to solve a real-world problem?

College is expensive. Scholarships.com has done the work for you. Pay for your college education with free college scholarship money. Get matched to college scholarships instantly and start applying today by conducting a free college scholarship search at Scholarships.com.

ADVERTISEMENT

Discuss

Share your thoughts and perhaps thousands of students will benefit from your unique insight on the subject!



If you can read this, don't touch the following fields


 

Dawnela W  on  8/20/2012 1:41:48 PM commented:

I don't believe he should have been punished at all. He solved a problem most colleges/universities are facing right now and probably don't have a site or a service like that for students. If his total was only $7.78 how much do you think he's charging for the site? Chump change or even taking in donations like most freeware sites do. Money shouldn't even have been and issue since around 8 dollars is nothing anyways. Let him off with a warning about the money and thought of ways to incorporate it into the school. As far as it being a "disruption" I think it was just another sad excuse to get him on Academic Probation.

Seth W  on  8/19/2012 11:22:21 AM commented:

University presidents and coaches get paid humongous amounts of money each year that way overcompensates for their usefulness to society (or rather lack thereof), and UCF is crying about losing a piddly 8 dollars? Every other school I know of gives priority for registration to students with the highest number of credits, regardless of whether or not they are disabled, international, PSEO, whatever. There's absolutely no reason that a senior shouldn't be able to get registered for any classes they need before they graduate. Yet another blight on the ugly face of American colleges, right up there with the shenanigans the law schools pulled by fabricating post-graduation employment prospects in the law profession to lure students (when the failing economy took all the law jobs with it). There should be a criminal investigation into UCF's handling of this episode.

Khaleel A  on  8/16/2012 12:44:04 PM commented:

He should have been praised for his creativity, not punished for it. Isn't the purpose of education is to get students to think critically and apply their knowledge efficiently? That's exactly what Mr. Arnold was doing. I'm disappointed in UCF...

Joseph D  on  8/16/2012 12:28:26 PM commented:

Maybe a little bit of a slap on the wrist is called for because of the use of school tech. But, not only was the punishment too harsh, I think he should charge for the service. He designed a new technology. That takes time and effort. His idea, his right to charge. Tim, I recommend looking at selling the license for the use of your program to colleges all over the U.S.. You have a good idea that is marketable and should be compensated for it.

Maiki V  on  8/14/2012 11:40:28 AM commented:

Samual S.... You missed the 2nd half of what UCF punished him for ..."it disrupted normal technology use." So he would have been punished even it he hadn't made almost $8 because he "disrupted normal technology use." So he is being punished for trying to solve a real world problem.

Haley T  on  8/14/2012 12:25:36 AM commented:

I feel that they should have only given him minimal punishment, as despite the cause it was violating a few rules. Make him return the money, and maybe have a minor academic punishment (I don't know any specifics along those means.) However, they should have also offered to sustain his idea by more rule-appropriate, legal means. It truely is a good idea. Overall, UCF overexaggerated quite a bit when dealing with the situation. Making a point is one thing--overkill is another.

Kodria H  on  8/13/2012 3:30:43 PM commented:

I don't think that Tim should have been put on academic probation. He probably shouldn't have been charing for it, but he shouldn't have been punished to that extreem.

Samuel S  on  8/13/2012 11:13:09 AM commented:

"Was it fair to put a proactive student on academic probation for trying to solve a real-world problem?" he's not being punished for trying to solve a real-world problem. He's being punished for charging for it. Good for you, UCF.

 on  8/13/2012 10:19:33 AM commented:

Wow, talk about overdramatic. The charging other students to use the website I can understand, but just creating it shouldnt be a problem...

Adelle Lorraine d  on  8/12/2012 4:03:01 AM commented:

Wow, I think that's ridiculous. UCF needs to change their judgement; it doesn't look good on them. No one would want to attend a university whose officials have no logic, reasoning, or understanding!

Saundra G  on  8/11/2012 5:48:32 PM commented:

You go Tim Arnold! What he did was amazing and should NEVER be punished for such a compassionate act. The only one who should be punished are the school systems! They are deliberately setting students up to fail rather than succeed. I mean, first of all they give 1st priority to disabled and EOPS students who usually end up dropping the classes that so many other people need in order graduate! I'm not against these students but I feel that everyone should have an equal opportunity to register for classes. Disabled people want to be treated like everyone else so why handicap them in this area? Colleges should be paying Tim Arnold for concocting such a brilliant idea but instead they are punishing him because he found a way around their crooked system! My sister has been waiting for 1 chemistry class for 3 years now! She could have been started her career if it hadnt been for this waitlist crap! Those type of students should have priority if anyone should! I congradulate you Tim, don't let this evil system bring you down, you did a wonderful and kind thing for your fellow peers and God will bless you for it.

Brittney C  on  8/10/2012 8:16:09 PM commented:

Ridiculous of UCF.

Eric C  on  8/10/2012 3:12:27 PM commented:

To say the least, UCF, was probably embarassed that a student took it in his hands to solve a very frustrating issue. Wondering, "how come we did not think of it?" Ucf definitely over reacted. Tim Arnold, should have been praised instead of punished. OK, maybe he should not have charged anyone…donate the money to the student Union, then…and call it even.

Tiara S  on  8/10/2012 2:50:15 PM commented:

I think that he was not wrong for creating the website..it was only to help students but most universities just want to make all the money and profit and are very greedy. The degrees we get are not even worth all the money that we college students pay to earn them..these universities are money making businesses and thats simply it..most of them dont care about students getting quality education but only ripping every cent and dime from us students and if you are taking less than $8 away from them its a problem

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
We want to wish all of our Jewish students a Happy Hanukkah! May you enjoy lots of family time and laughter this holiday season. During your final nights of Hanukkah, we hope you get your fill of delicious latkes, dreidel games, gift opening and great memories.

Jewish Student Scholarship Spotlight

December 3, 2021 2:36 PM
by Liz Montenegro
We want to wish all of our Jewish students a Happy Hanukkah! May you enjoy lots of family time and laughter this holiday season. During your final nights of Hanukkah, we hope you get your fill of
Adam Sandler undoubtedly paved the way in bringing the celebration of Hanukkah to the forefront of pop culture with his wildly famous “Hanukkah” song debut in 1994 on Saturday Night Live (did you know there is now a “Hanukkah” Part 4?). In the song, Sandler draws attention to famous Jews in mainstream culture. You may be wondering which celebrities are observing Hanukkah this year. Before we dive into Hollywood, let’s answer the question of why these “eight CRAZY nights” are celebrated by millions of Jewish people across the globe.

Hanukkah 2021: Celebrities You Didn’t Know Were Jewish

December 2, 2021 3:20 PM
by Liz Montenegro
Adam Sandler undoubtedly paved the way in bringing the celebration of Hanukkah to the forefront of pop culture with his wildly famous “Hanukkah” song debut in 1994 on Saturday Night Live (did you
Starting college is a very exciting time. Dorm life is full of new experiences, and many scholarships are available that can help cover the cost of your room and board. Like everything else, there are pros and cons to living in a college dorm.

College Dorms: Should You Give On-Campus Living a Try?

November 30, 2021 4:02 PM
by Liz Montenegro
Starting college is a very exciting time. Dorm life is full of new experiences, and many scholarships are available that can help cover the cost of your room and board. Like everything else, there
When asked the question, “Who was your favorite teacher or coach growing up?” For most anyone, an image of that educator’s face immediately pops up in their mind. What was it about that person that made them stand out? Maybe it was the way they encouraged or inspired you as no others had previously done. Perhaps they saw something in you that helped you to gain the confidence to achieve a goal that had once seemed unattainable. The truth is, there are as many answers to this question as there are people in this world. One common denominator unites them: it all started with the foundation of mutual respect and trust this individual established with you.

This Week is American Education Week 2021

November 18, 2021 1:54 PM
by Liz Montenegro
When asked the question, “Who was your favorite teacher or coach growing up?” For most anyone, an image of that educator’s face immediately pops up in their mind. What was it about that person that
Since the beginning of our nation, Native Americans and Indigenous communities have been a powerful influence on modern U.S. society. Although art, beadwork, music and dancing may first come to mind when you think of Native American contributions to today’s culture, did you know that many of the foods we consider to be staples, such as potatoes, wild rice, beans, corn, and peanuts were first grown and harvested by Native Americans? Not only that, but Native American groups also taught European settlers some of their farming techniques to help them survive and live off of the land, many of those practices are still used today. American Indians were also the inventors of goods we rely on every day, like topical pain relievers, baby bottles, and even rubber products.

In November, We Celebrate Native American Heritage Month

November 12, 2021 4:07 PM
by Liz Montenegro
Since the beginning of our nation, Native Americans and Indigenous communities have been a powerful influence on modern U.S. society. Although art, beadwork, music and dancing may first come to mind
Are you a high school student looking for opportunities to help others around you and set yourself apart on college applications? With the holiday season in full swing, this is the perfect time to start your search for volunteering opportunities in your area. Along with strengthening ties to your community, serving as a volunteer demonstrates to colleges that you have given your time and energy to help those in need, and that you have applied the knowledge you’ve gained in your studies to real-world settings. Many college applications and scholarships have a minimum number of community service hours that their applicants must complete in order to be eligible. But just because it is a requirement, doesn’t mean it cannot also be a meaningful experience.

Community Service Benefits Everyone

November 8, 2021 3:12 PM
by Liz Montenegro
Are you a high school student looking for opportunities to help others around you and set yourself apart on college applications? With the holiday season in full swing, this is the perfect time to
 With Veteran’s Day quickly approaching, what better way to honor our U.S. military members and their families than to shine a spotlight on the scholarships and grants available to them? Military life often presents unique challenges that can be overwhelming for the entire family. Lengthy deployments and frequent changes of station are just a few obstacles military families face, but their strength and perseverance through these hardships is truly remarkable. As a way to honor their sacrifices, Scholarships.com offers a wide variety of grants and scholarships to help offset the cost of college as they pursue their educational goals.

Scholarships for Military Members and Dependents

October 29, 2021 3:24 PM
by Liz Montenegro
With Veteran’s Day quickly approaching, what better way to honor our U.S. military members and their families than to shine a spotlight on the scholarships and grants available to them? Military
FAFSA is an acronym. It stands for Free Application for Federal Student Aid. Please take note that the first word in the acronym is Free. You do not need to pay to fill out the FAFSA but there are certainly websites out there that will charge you for their assistance. If you are asked for a credit card at any point in the process, you are at one of these sites. If you do not want to pay to complete the FAFSA, be sure to apply at https://studentaid.gov/h/apply-for-aid/fafsa. The FAFSA must be completed by you and your family each year if you wish to be considered for need-based grants from the college or university you are or will be attending as well as subsidized student loans.

What is the FAFSA?

October 8, 2021 2:52 PM
by Scholarships.com Staff
FAFSA is an acronym. It stands for "Free Application for Federal Student Aid". Please take note that the first word in the acronym is "Free". You do not need to pay to fill out the FAFSA but there
A study abroad program can be the beginning of the most exciting chapter of your college experience. Often, the travel, housing, credits and even food are included in the price of the program you choose. However, this is no reason not to look for more financial opportunities!

Want to Study Abroad? Find Scholarships

August 31, 2021 12:30 PM
by Scholarships.com Staff
A study abroad program can be the beginning of the most exciting chapter of your college experience. Often, the travel, housing, credits and even food are included in the price of the program you
As you get ready for this next big step in your life, this last year at home can feel like the longest and the shortest you ever had! While you prepare to select a college and research scholarships and financial aid, don’t forget to spend some quality time with your friends and family. While movies, even when based on a true story, are always a little bit fantastic, they are also works of art that share experiences among their viewers.

Movie Night! College Classics

August 19, 2021 12:22 PM
by Scholarships.com Staff
As you get ready for this next big step in your life, this last year at home can feel like the longest and the shortest you ever had! While you prepare to select a college and research scholarships