Auctioning Off College Admissions Seats?


April 2, 2019 3:47 PM
by Susan Dutca-Lovell
Why not have schools auction off college seats to the highest bidder? The question was posed by a senior vice president at the Harvard Management Company on his public LinkedIn page amid the recent national college admissions cheating scandal. According to Michael Cappucci, it is simply an honest question. He goes on to ask, Why do we have a system where wealthy parents have to make shady payments to even more shady intermediaries to get their kids into college? The post, which has since been removed but still drew much online anger was authored by Cappucci who is not a top official at the company; many people still presumed Harvard is connected to his idea, according to Inside Higher Ed, but Harvard was quick to distance itself from the LinkedIn post.

Why not have schools auction off college seats to the highest bidder? The question was posed by a senior vice president at the Harvard Management Company on his public LinkedIn page amid the recent national college admissions cheating scandal. According to Michael Cappucci, it is simply "an honest question." He goes on to ask, "Why do we have a system where wealthy parents have to make shady payments to even more shady intermediaries to get their kids into college?" The post, which has since been removed but still drew much online anger was authored by Cappucci who is "not a top official" at the company; many people still presumed Harvard is connected to his idea, according to Inside Higher Ed, but Harvard was quick to distance itself from the LinkedIn post.

In a way, one might argue the idea of auctioning off admissions slots is not that far-fetched, especially when you consider that colleges - who have already filled up slots designated for students who require financial aid - also reserve space for families that do not require financial need. In these cases, wealth is "the deciding factor" in filling the remaining seats. Therefore, perhaps an auction would be a more transparent way for wealthier families to "compete with the 'charade' of the status quo," according to Cappucci. While the proposal may not be "socially just," it would at least be "as socially just and more transparent than is the current system." Besides, we may as well "force the wealthy to pay more for their good fortune," stated Robert Samuelson, an economics columnist who proposed a similar system.

How would an ideal bidding system exist? For starters, students would have to "meet the school's high academic standards;" bargaining would not be permitted, as "the award of admissions sports would be strictly determined by the price offered;" and preference for children of alumni would not be allowed (also known as legacy admissions.)

Furthermore, all winning bids would be required to pay, so that if the applicant applied to multiple schools but chose one, they would still have to pay their winning bids for all of the other schools. This would help more than just the wealthy, as auction revenue could be funneled into scholarships for the poor and middle class, bringing "more, not less, equality."

Those who advocate for the auctioning of college seats are asking: "Would they be worse than a situation where wealthy donors' children are admitted without any transparency?" Yes or no? Why or why not? Let us know your thoughts in the comment section below.

Getting more college financial aid doesn’t have to be a relentless search. Scholarships.com is totally free. Connect with our massive database of millions of college scholarships at any time by searching for awards in a variety of ways. Scholarships.com offers the quickest and easiest way to search for, apply to, and win college scholarships. Start making your college education affordable or perhaps even free, by conducting a free college scholarship search at Scholarships.com.

Discuss

Share your thoughts and perhaps thousands of students will benefit from your unique insight on the subject!



If you can read this, don't touch the following fields


 

Anonymous  on  5/16/2019 4:17:35 PM commented:

While the solution that "there are no free rides" might be ideal for some, isn't that the point of private, rich kid tutoring? To give the kid and academic advantage? I think the extra transparency could be nice, but schools can't be forced to give all equally. If you have more money and/or bring more fame, the school benefits more from your presence. At least the facade gives the impression that the admission process is fair... I guess the free market does ensure that this would never happen, as the bad press from any school actually doing this would be enough to form a backlash that would make getting into the school undesirable...

nothanks  on  4/9/2019 8:55:22 PM commented:

This seems like it would be a better system than the one in place now, but better doesn't equal best, or even good. Even if this system was implemented, what's stopping the rich kids who don't qualify from going back to shady deals? The problem here isn't rich kids who meet the requirements (although that can be a problem at times, it's a different conversation), the current problem is rich kids who don't meet the requirements trying to bribe their way into a school they wouldn't otherwise be able to get into.

Kurt H  on  4/8/2019 2:09:51 PM commented:

I am sorry, but this suggestion is absolutely ludicrous!! Whatever happened to the idea that one EARNS their way in life. There are no free rides. Every high school student should have the same opportunity at higher education regardless of Mommy and Daddy's income level. If you can't make the grade, maybe it's time for Mommy and Daddy to stop babying their kids and teach how to work harder and earn it!!!!

Shelley S  on  4/7/2019 10:29:07 PM commented:

Haven’t the spots at elite schools been essentially auctioned off for years...? If you donate enough money to the school, you’re buying your kid a spot there.

Mai  on  4/2/2019 6:20:38 PM commented:

Well this idea is sure going to make it easier for this country's elites get ALL of the seats. If everyone meets the schools requirements, so that it is an even playing field, then the only differential will be the cash. There you have it! It's the have's against the have not's. The elites win again!


    In honor of LGBTQ Pride Month this June, Scholarships.com is recognizing the success of, and providing financial aid resources to the lesbian, gay, bi-sexual, transgender, and queer community and its allies through featured LGBTQ scholarships. These colorful LGBTQ scholarships are not only intended for those who identify as LBTQ or are questioning, but are available to LGBTQ parents and allies, as well. Below is a preview of LGBTQ scholarships that were created to provide economic mobility and equality for LGBTQ students and allies who may face unique challenges on their educational journeys. For even more LGBTQ scholarships, Parent LGBTQ scholarships or LGBTQ Ally scholarships, visit here.

LGBTQ Scholarships for Pride Month

June 6, 2019 3:22 PM
by Susan Dutca-Lovell
In honor of LGBTQ Pride Month this June, Scholarships.com is recognizing the success of, and providing financial aid resources to the lesbian, gay, bi-sexual, transgender, and queer community

    We're bringing the heat with these fiery summer scholarships for which you can apply this summer break. While scholarships are offered year-round, many students have more free time during the summer to devote to scholarship essays and applications, so we encourage you to prioritize financial aid in-between basking in the sun.

Sizzling Summer 2019 Scholarships

June 5, 2019 11:21 AM
by Susan Dutca-Lovell
We're bringing the heat with these fiery summer scholarships for which you can apply this summer break. While scholarships are offered year-round, many students have more free time during the
 China's Ministry of Education is warning its students about studying in the United States in its first study abroad alert of the year. Students are advised to prepare accordingly given the potential difficulties in acquiring visas since the visa review period has been extended, the validity period has been shortened and the refusal rate has increased.

China Warns Students Against Studying in the U.S.

June 4, 2019 4:24 PM
by Susan Dutca-Lovell
China's Ministry of Education is warning its students about studying in the United States in its first "study abroad alert" of the year. Students are advised to "prepare accordingly" given the
Affluent families allegedly abused the system by acquiring faulty learning disability diagnoses in order to gain extra time on the SAT or ACT, according to recent reports on the college admissions scandal. In some incidents, some corrupt proctors took the tests for the students or corrected their answers.

Issues of SAT Equality, from Testing to Scoring

May 28, 2019 11:27 AM
by Susan Dutca-Lovell
Affluent families allegedly abused the system by acquiring faulty learning disability diagnoses in order to gain extra time on the SAT or ACT, according to recent reports on the college admissions
Ciara will soon one, two step in the halls of Harvard University's prestigious Business School according to her latest Instagram post in which she shared the good news of being accepted into the Business of Entertainment, Media and Sports program while donning a Harvard sweatshirt. The $10,000 program, which spans over the course of three days is open to talent and individuals active in the entertainment industry, according to Harvard Business School's website.

Ciara Levels Up, Headed to Harvard Business School

May 21, 2019 3:51 PM
by Susan Dutca-Lovell
Ciara will soon "one, two step" in the halls of Harvard University's prestigious Business School according to her latest Instagram post in which she shared the good news of being accepted into the
For a 72-year-old grandmother, graduating from college with a bachelor's degree from The University of New Mexico was better late than never. To top that off, Rigina Wright also graduated at the top of her class as Valedictorian with a 4.067 GPA.

Graduating Grandma Garners Top Honor of Valedictorian

May 14, 2019 11:14 AM
by Susan Dutca-Lovell
For a 72-year-old grandmother, graduating from college with a bachelor's degree from The University of New Mexico was "better late than never." To top that off, Rigina Wright also graduated at the
Democratic presidential candidate Senator Elizabeth Warren is proposing the elimination of existing college student loan debt for millions of Americans; over 42 million individuals.

Warren Pitches Loan Forgiveness, Free College Education

April 23, 2019 3:17 PM
by Susan Dutca-Lovell
Democratic presidential candidate Senator Elizabeth Warren is proposing the elimination of existing college student loan debt for millions of Americans; over 42 million individuals. According to